Artisan jewelry, gift and whisky shops pack the main street of the main town on the Orkney Islands. The town even boasts a new Japanese restaurant, serving packed meals and matcha cheesecake.
Historically inhabited by the Norse rulers who governed the islands, the town has hit it rich: it tops the UK’s charts for cruise ship arrivals, as American, German and Mediterranean tourists descend on remarkable neolithic sites such as Skara Brae and its historic church.
But numerous local residents are frustrated: hosting about half a million visitors a year, 20 times the resident count of twenty-two thousand, has a significant impact. The islands' small streets are jammed, public buses overwhelmed, the neolithic stones at Brodgar are now barricaded to fix the wear and tear by visitors. A number of visitors, unable to find restrooms, have reportedly been found defecating in the open.
Struggling to Cover the Expenses of Visitor Facilities
Struggling to pay for the expenses of developing new restrooms, coach parks and walkways to adequately accommodate visitors, the local authority and its business leaders are seeking the power to establish a novel fee for every tourist who lands on the islands, by either sea or flight.
Orkney islands council has teamed up with the Shetland Islands and Western Isles council to urge the Scottish government to legislate for a point of entry levy included in fares set by ship companies, boat services and the islands airline the regional airline.
Martin Fleet, managing director of the family-owned jewelry business Sheila Fleet, and chair of the business group Destination Orkney, projects that a standard five pound charge for every visitor could generate around £2m a year, after operational expenses are subtracted.
“Orkney, Shetland, the Outer Hebrides, which have limited residents, have remarkable sites which people want to visit and explore, but we’ve got to ensure that we preserve those assets for posterity who live here and also those that want to visit,” he explained.
“It's not our intention for people to cease coming here. We simply require to be highly conscious about how tourism is handled.”
Authorities Reviewing Entry Fee Options
The Scottish government has stated it is considering a arrival surcharge as part of a wider review on introducing a charge specifically for passenger vessels, which local governments with popular harbors could deploy for new tourism infrastructure and local services.
Local officials emphatically state that tourist levies are required to support a £647m gap in government funding and to assist in managing the vast numbers of tourists the country welcomes each year. Outcomes of the review are due out shortly.
The nation currently possesses the UK’s pioneering legislation to allow local authorities to introduce a “bed tax” – a visitor levy on hotels, B&Bs and campsites. Edinburgh’s has come into force, with tourists now paying a 5% surcharge on every booking reserved from 24 July 2026 forward, limited at a week.
Aberdeen and Glasgow are adopting similar measures, but other councils across the northern regions have declined that approach, frequently after a opposition from enterprises, insisting a charge on beds is excessively onerous and is also off-putting for customers.
Alternative Approaches for Remote Areas
The Shetland Islands has turned down a visitor levy; Orkney and the Western Isles have “paused” it, anticipating a more suitable alternative such as a arrival surcharge arrives.
Cruise Scotland, an trade association, has protested that a passenger vessel levy will deter many of the 1.2 million passengers who arrive each year, “causing significant consequences for the nation's cruise sector, its fragile seaside communities, and the nation's standing as a globally competitive travel hotspot”.
Local authorities states a point of entry levy treats every visitor fairly. It covers the 214,000 passenger liner travelers who landed there in last year and the one hundred seventy-three thousand who arrived by boat and flight, including RV users, outdoor enthusiasts and lodging patrons, and those on private yachts.
The council and Historic Environment Scotland, the agency which protects Orkney’s neolithic UNESCO site, are engaged in an exhaustive initiative to construct a recently planned tourist center, coach parks, walking routes and facilities to accommodate numbers at the Ring of Brodgar and prehistoric settlement.
Partly funded by the islands growth deal set up by the national administrations, that may take up to a decade to complete: constructing on a protected heritage site is a careful process.
Local and Industry Viewpoints
Christie Hartley, the council’s sustainable tourism lead, said the national authorities required to outline its plans promptly, to avoid the shipping industry “getting riled up”, but she explained a fee would advantage all sides.
“In general, there is little relationship usually between cruise lines and the local residents that they sell – they market two things: the journey of their ships and our places,” she said.
Although they have a very strong partnership with bus operators and port officials, “what about the local populations that we have a mandate to safeguard and support? This is a significant opportunity for us to actually build those relationships to shared advantage.
“If we invest in infrastructure, they can enhance the visit for their guests, they can charge more, they can have the security of being certain what they’re going to get. It's well known we have issues with the lack of toilets and aspects in our fragile community that are difficult to manage with the number of people.”
A local councillor, a councillor and head of Orkney’s planning and facilities board, commented tourists are increasingly eco-conscious and conscientious. “There’s an open door there: to have a effective system in operation, to have a good relationship and for this levy to actually prove highly beneficial,” he concluded.